![]() |
|
|||||||
| Register | FAQ | Members List | Calendar | Search | Today's Posts | Mark Forums Read |
| Experiences/Stories While Carrying Share your CCW stories here |
![]() |
|
|
LinkBack | Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
|||
|
You kept cool, sized up the BG's demeaner and did what you thought was best in the situation you were in. No sense in second guessing or arm chair quarterbacking, as you said at the end of the day, everyone went home.
Host - please delete if necessary. A rhetorical question .....(or PM me as this may be forum-ly incorrect) if the BG would have had a completley different demeanor, one that was agressive and menacing, would one need to give him the opportunity to turn around and face you like the old west chivalrous conduct (knowing he was armed and dangerous) thereby giving him a chance to draw and fire? It would be advantagous for a subjective subject matter of "when to shoot/confront", or perhaps more appropriately, "when not to shoot/confront". Seems to me that XD did what was right for him. The obvious downside to society is that the BG is still at large and may eventually shoot someone else.
__________________
"Smoke em if ya got em" |
|
||||
|
XD in OC: You did the right thing IMHO. You were a good witness and everyone went home unhurt. Good job.
OCCCW: How I understand the law, you must be in fear for your life or in fear for someone else's life for a shoot to be justified. I think you would be justified if you take down a BG who's back is turned to you if said BG is holding a gun to someone's head threatning to kill them. That said, I would probably try and distract them enough so that their gun is not pointed at anyone when I shoot. You never know what their trigger finger is going to do when hit by a .45
__________________
ChrisG "Inspector Feet" Zombielicious!!! |
|
||||
|
Quote:
__________________
Igitur qui desiderat pacem, praeparet bellum. Quote:
![]() Druid, reformed |
|
||||
|
You did the right thing.
__________________
"A kind word only goes so far, a kind word and a gun goes a lot further" Al Capone 1924 Be Safe, Be Confident, Get Trained! ® Copyrighted 1996 Amateurs Talk Hardware (Guns) Professionals Talk Software (Training) greg@firearmstraining.com Oh Yeah! Piss On Golf! Waste of a good range. |
|
||||
|
All I can say is wow!
That BG must have had an Angel looking over him. He will never know how close he came to taking his last breath last night. No way I can critique your actions as I was not there seeing it through your eyes. But it sounds like you did a good job. VERY glad to hear you and your coworkers made it out all in one piece! So I have to ask, what did the LEO say to you after the fact? Upon learning you had a CCW on you, any comment on why you did or did not act? |
|
|||
|
I think you did the right thing. You were ready to take him out if he did start shooting. Anyone working in your line of profession, like a banker, would know they're going to be robbed at some point. It's not going to fix the world by you detaining one individual at gun point until the police arrive. Especially considering this guy just seems to have wanted a fix. If this guy would have started using deadly force then I am sure you would have responded appropriately.
|
|
||||
|
How do your co-workers feel about your part in this scenario?
Also, good job ![]()
__________________
"I've read news articles of people getting shot up at bus stops, work, home, restraunts, and 5 year old's birthday parties. All places people would tell me I'd be crazy to bring a gun. And they were right, a crazy guy brought a gun." ~myself |
|
||||
|
Quote:
Quote:
You correctly and accurately accertained the threat level and were prepared to deal with it if it escalated to dire level. You should be proud of yourself . . . I'm pretty sure that the Forum is. ![]() |
|
||||
|
Great job! Self control, kept your awareness about you, and made quick decisions.
As far as force, I agree, a shooting here would have been questionable or worse. I don't think holding a gun to someone's head is needed to shoot the BG, but unless the BG demonstrates agressive behavior with the gun, it would be hard to say you felt your life was in immediate and imminent mortal danger. For example, if he shot a warning shot in the ceiling and then started waving and using the gun to frighten you to open the safe, etc, and at that point you felt your life was in danger, you might be justified in shooting in self defense. It has to come down to your perception of the level of threat against your life (your ceision based upon the circumstances). For most scenarios pictured against reality, it really boils down to the totality of the circumstances. (Immanence) Luckily, this guy just wanted his drugs.
__________________
"Saying a person has the right to defend themself, while not allowing them a CCW, is like espousing free speech as long as no verbs are involved." ~ Some really cool guy, circa 2007 "Mr. Heller maintains that disassembled rifles and shotguns are no substitute for handguns, "any more than the government could prohibit books because it permits newspapers and considers them an 'adequate substitute.'" " "America is at that awkward stage. It’s too late to change the system from within, yet too early to shoot the bastards." - Claire Wolf "SHIMH" Last edited by OCRancher : 12-11-2007 at 09:27 AM. |
![]() |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|